Good is...? Logo critique

In yesterdays workshop, we were required to choose 10 logos from our selection which we believed to have the most potential in terms of development and communication. As groups, we then had to critique the chosen logos of another group and select one which was the most effective. It was interesting to see how others have interpreted their 'good' and incoporated the concept into a logo. My top 10 logos, the chosen logo and the feedback I received are below:

Chosen logo:

Feedback

• Visually we thought this was the most interesting
• Relating pretty well to the subject matter
• Don't know how you could develop it further
• Other imagery - still within optimism
• Define it more into a logo - box it off? The type could go anywhere

Task for 12/10

Package 'nostalgia' using the logo (develop and explore)
Apply to the 4 given nets (below)
Design, experiment, mock up and finalise

Requirements:

2 colour and stock
Must maintain structural format but can be manipulated